Credit Acceptance (CACC) Fundamental Analysis: Bull vs. Bear Case

CACC

Credit Acceptance

Fundamental data last updated:April 13, 2026

We may earn a commission from partner links. This content is for informational purposes only and is not financial advice. Information may be delayed or inaccurate.

company profile

SECTOR

Financial Services

industry

Credit Services

Exchange

Nasdaq

County of HQ

United States

Next Earnings Date

04/29/26

Business Summary

Credit Acceptance operates as a specialty finance company focused on subprime auto lending, partnering with dealerships to originate high-yield consumer loans. The company generates cash by purchasing installment contracts at a discount and collecting payments over time, capturing spread between funding costs and borrower payments. Its moat is rooted in underwriting data, long-standing dealer relationships, and a servicing infrastructure built to manage higher-risk borrowers efficiently. Scale in loan performance data improves pricing precision, allowing it to accept risk others cannot while maintaining a 27.80% operating margin. The durability of its model depends on disciplined credit selection and consistent capital recycling rather than rapid balance sheet expansion.

VALUATION

P/E

12.8 Market Cap ($M USD)

$4,999

Forward P/E

9.2 PEG

1.2 PRICE TO SALES

2.4 PRICE TO BOOK

3.3 EV / EBITDA

17.5 5-Year Average P/E

Free Cash Flow Yield

DCF Value

Graham Number

Price to FCF

EV to FCF

Earnings Yield

FCF Yield

DIVIDEND

Yield

-

Annual Payout

-

Payout Ratio

-

Consecutive Years of Dividend Growth

0 5-Year Dividend Growth Rate

-

Financial Health & Profitability

Earnings Per Share

$37.02

Next Year EPS Growth Estimate

$50.75

Next Year Revenue Growth Estimate

6.00%

Return on Equity (ROE)

27.80%

FREE CASH FLOW

Operating Margin

27.10%

Debt-to-Equity

4.2 Piotroski F-Score

7 Altman Z-Score

2.2 Return on Invested Capital (ROIC)

5.10%

Current Ratio

21.2 Quick Ratio

Net Debt to EBITDA

Interest Coverage

Gross Profit margin

FCF PER SHARE

REVENUE PER SHARE

Gainseekers Quantitative Analysis

Summary

At 12.8x earnings and just 9.2x forward earnings, CACC is trading like a no-growth lender despite an EPS step-up from 17.5 to an estimated 37.02 next year, which is a dramatic inflection embedded in the forward multiple. A PEG of 1.2 suggests growth is being priced reasonably rather than exuberantly, while a Piotroski F-Score of 7 signals fundamentally solid operations. However, the Altman Z-Score of 2.2 places the company in a gray zone where balance sheet risk cannot be ignored. This is not a distressed balance sheet, but it is not fortress-grade either—meaning the valuation discount is at least partially justified. Overall, the stock screens as a statistically cheap, moderately risky compounder rather than a deep value anomaly.

AI Exposure / Tech Reliance

As a Credit Services company, CACC operates in a data-intensive underwriting environment where AI-driven risk modeling can materially enhance loan performance. The industry’s shift toward algorithmic credit assessment favors players with scale and historical loan performance data. If CACC effectively integrates machine learning into underwriting and collections, it can reinforce margin durability and reduce credit losses.

The Bull Case

A value-oriented investor buys this because the numbers show operational discipline and embedded earnings power. An operating margin of 27.80% in Financial Services is substantial, demonstrating strong pricing power and cost control. The Piotroski F-Score of 7 indicates improving financial strength and operational quality, while ROIC at 5.10% and ROE at 6.00% suggest steady, if not explosive, capital returns that can scale meaningfully if the projected EPS of 37.02 materializes. A forward P/E of 9.2 against that earnings ramp creates a classic GARP setup—paying a single-digit multiple for a business with tangible forward growth. Add in a 4.2 TTM yield and institutional ownership listed at 475.50, and you have signals of capital return and institutional engagement that support valuation stability.

The Bear Case

There are structural concerns that cannot be dismissed. Debt/Equity at 27.10% may appear manageable, but in a credit-driven model, leverage amplifies downside risk during credit contractions. The Altman Z-Score of 2.2 keeps the firm out of the “safe” zone, meaning balance sheet deterioration in a recession is a realistic risk. A PEG of 1.2 implies growth is already being priced in fairly, so upside may be capped if EPS growth disappoints. ROIC of 5.10% is not elite for a lender taking credit risk, and ROE at 6.00% is modest, suggesting the business is not extracting extraordinary returns from equity capital.

Market Sentiment & Smart Money

Short Interest %

30.80%

Analyst Consensus

2.6 Average Analyst Price Target

$475.50

Institutional Ownership %

78.60%

1-Year Beta

1.5 Insider Buying % (6 Mo)

50.00%%

Distance to 52-Week High

84.60%

Distance to 52-Week Low

115.70%

EARNINGS SURPRISE %

50-DAY SMA

200-DAY SMA

⚠️ Financial Disclaimer:
This content is for informational purposes only and is not financial advice. Information may be delayed or inaccurate. We may earn a commission from partner links.